
UNCLE OSWALD’S Q&A FORUM – OCTOBER 2026
EARLY DISMISSAL APPLICATIONS
Dear Uncle Oswald,
It is me again, Fearless Frikkie.
I am again involved in an arbitration, this time as the respondent/contractor. The arbitral proceedings are governed by the 2021 edition of the Standard Procedure Rules for the Conduct of Arbitrations (the Rules) published by the Association of Arbitrators (Southern Africa).
I have delivered my statement of defence to the claimant/employer’s claim. The claim is based on an alleged termination of the underlying construction contract, as a consequence of which the claimant now seeks an award for damages against me. In my statement of defence, I deny that the alleged termination was lawful. I specifically plead that the contract requires a compulsory written breach notice from the claimant placing me in mora and providing me with 14 working days within which to rectify the alleged breach. It is common cause from the pleadings and the correspondence between the parties that the claimant never issued the compulsory written breach notice. The claimant simply issued a notice of termination.
What has happened now is that the claimant delivered an application in terms of article 25.1(a) of the Rules in which it seeks an award by the Arbitrator to the effect that my statement of defence be dismissed on the basis that it is manifestly without merit.
I have never before dealt with an application in terms of article 25 of the Rules and I am unable to find any South African authority on point. Could you please enlighten me?
Yours faithfully,
Fearless Frikkie
___________________________________________________________________________
Dear Frikkie,
Fearless and mostly successful as you are, I would urge you to seek advice from an experienced construction law practitioner when you prepare your response to the claimant’s article 25 application for the early dismissal of your defence.
In the meantime, I can certainly provide you with a summary of what article 25 of the Rules involves and point you in the direction of international authorities. I shall do so as follows:
THE RULES
- In Article 25.1 of the Rules determines in relevant part as follows:
-
-
-
- Early Dismissal of Claims and Defences
-
-
-
-
-
- A party may apply to the arbitral tribunal for the early dismissal of a claim or defence on the basis that:
-
-
(a) A claim or defence is manifestly without merit; or
(b) A claim or defence is manifestly outside the jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal.
(My emphasis)
- The claimant’s Early Dismissal Application concerns the question whether your defence is manifestly without merit as contemplated in article 25.1(1) of the Rules.
THE DISPUTE
- On my understanding of what you have conveyed to me, the claimant relies on termination of a contract and your defence relies on a denial that the claimant followed the contractually prescribed mandatory procedure for a lawful termination of the contract.
THE ISSUE FOR DETERMINATION
- As such, the sole question for determination against the aforesaid background is whether your defence is manifestly without merit.
- The test to be applied for purposes of the Early Dismissal Application is governed by the word ‘manifestly‘.
THE MEANING OF THE WORD ‘MANIFESTLY’
- Common sense and basic linguistic proficiency dictate that, for something to be manifest, it has to be clear in appearance. In this case it means that the defence apparent from your statement of defence must be clearly and in appearance, from the statement of defence itself, lack merit.
- The Concise Oxford English Dictionary states that, for something to be manifest (derivative: manifestly), it has to be clear or obvious to the eye. A “manifestation” is an event, action or object that clearly shows or embodies something. Its origin lies in the Latin word manifestare which means “make public“.
- The Concise Oxford Thesaurus states that “manifest” means to show, exhibit, demonstrate, present or reveal.
- On this basis, an example of a claim that is manifestly without merit would be a delictual damages claim by a farmer against a government for pecuniary loss arising from a natural disaster such as drought. Such a claim obviously/manifestly does not disclose a recognised cause of action in law.
- Similarly, an example of a defence that is manifestly without merit would be a student’s defence against a bank’s loan agreement claim to the effect that the student does not have any money to repay the loan on the due date. Such a defence obviously/manifestly does not disclose a recognised defence in law.
THE NATURE OF AN EARLY DISMISSAL APPLICATION
- For purposes of the Early Dismissal Application, in the context of article 25 of the Rules, the word “manifestly” in itself dictates that the test:
| (a) | Is objective (i.e. clear to any reader); and |
| (b) | Must be applied to your statement of defence as it stands (i.e. without resorting to evidence concerning the merits of the dispute (which would defeat the expediting purpose of the exercise). |
- An application in terms of article 25 of the Rules is therefore, in most cases, a papers-only application. The tribunal is confined, first, to the claim as expressed in the statement of claim and, second, to the corresponding defence as expressed in the statement of defence. In other words, the tribunal is obliged to test whether the statement of defence discloses a defence to the claim which constitutes a triable issue, in other words a bona fide (in the sense as envisaged in Maharaj) defence which is good in law.
- The position is comparable to well-known procedures in litigious actions, for example, exceptions and summary judgment applications. They all have the expediting aim of avoiding perceived disputes which obviously/manifestly are without merit, from proceeding to a hearing which would only waste time and resources.
AUTHORITIES
- The early / summary dismissal / determination of claims and defences is a procedure provided for in most recognised arbitration rules worldwide including the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) rules, the International Court of Arbitration (ICC) rules, the Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre (HKIAC) rules, the London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA) rules and the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) rules.
- Universally, these procedures aim to enhance arbitral efficiency by rejecting claims or defences which obviously/manifestly lack merit at an early stage, thereby saving time and costs.
- It is both self-evident and universally accepted that this procedure exists to avoid the waste of time and costs of a full arbitration hearing in the event of claims or defences that are obviously/manifestly without merit.
- Early dismissal proceedings are not to be confused with what is generally known as expedited arbitration proceedings. Expedited arbitration proceedings are full arbitration proceedings with evidence and argument, albeit in accordance with shortened timeframes. In early dismissal proceedings, however, the parties do not go through the arbitral process and do not submit their evidence. The merits of the dispute are not considered, only the question whether a claim or defence is obviously/manifestly without merit.
- Early dismissal proceedings do therefor generally not include an evidence hearing, which would defeat its expediting purpose.
- As such, and for these reasons, all of the aforesaid arbitration rules universally include the word “manifestly” in their formulation.
- A case in point is the notes to parties and tribunals issued by the ICC on the conduct of arbitrations under the ICC rules.[1] Paragraphs 93 to 98 of the guidance notes deal with the determination of manifestly unmeritorious claims or defences. The essence of these guidance notes includes that:
| (a) | The aim of an early dismissal procedure is the expeditious determination and, if warranted, the dismissal of manifestly unmeritorious claims or defences; and |
| (b) | The presentation of evidence will only be allowed in exceptional circmstances. |
- Another illustration in point is the ICSID tribunal award in the international investment arbitration between Mainstream Renewable Power Ltd and Others v Federal Republic of Germany:[2]
| (a) | In Mainstream the applicant unsuccessfully placed reliance on rule 41(5) of the ICSID Rules of Procedure for Arbitration Proceedings (the ICSID Rules) which is worded in terms of similar to article 25 of the Rules. Rule 41(5) of the ICSID Rules similarly provides for the early dismissal of a claim or defence which is manifestly without merit; |
| (b) | From the unanimous 2022 award of the tribunal in Mainstream, written by Wendy Miles QC as President of the three-member tribunal, the following is apparent: |
| (i) | As to the meaning of the phrase “manifestly“, the claim or defence must be clearly and obviously without merit “as a matter of law” and the application of this standard requires a “high degree of clarity” of the alleged lack of merit. |
| (ii) | As authority for the aforesaid, the tribunal in Mainstream referred to the ICSID arbitral award in Trans-Global v Jordan( another unsuccessful application for early dismissal in terms of rule 41(5) of the ICSID Rules), where the tribunal stated in respect of the phrased “manifestly without merit“, that “standard is thus set high” and requires of an applicant in terms of ICSID Rule 41(5) “to establish its objection clearly and obviously, with relative ease and despatch“. The tribunal in Trans-Global noted that “Rule 41(5) can only apply to a clear and obvious case“, or to “patently unmeritorious” claims or defences. |
| (iii) | The tribunal in Mainstream further relied on the ICSID arbitral award in Lotus v Turkmenistan (also an unsuccessful application for early dismissal in terms of rule 41(5) of the ICSID Rule 41 (5) that it must be “obvious from the submissions (pleadings) of the parties that there is some unavoidable and undisputable fact, or some legal objection in relation to which no possible counter-argument is identified“. Therefore, if the opposing party “can point to an arguable case, the claim should proceed” and the application in terms of ICSID Rule 41(5) must fail. |
| (iv) | The tribunal in Mainstream also referred to the ICSID arbitral award in PNG v Papua New Guinea (a further unsuccessful application for early dismissal in terms of rule 41(5) of the ICSID Rules) wherein the tribunal stated that ICSID Rule 41(5) applies only to “undisputed or genuinely indisputable rules of law or to uncontested facts“. The tribunal stated that this was so, because the ICSID Rule 41(5) procedure would “inevitably limit the Parties’ opportunity to be heard and the Tribunal’s opportunity to reflect“.. |
IN SUMMARY
- The procedure for early dismissal of a manifestly unmeritorious defence as provided for in article 25.1(1) of the Rules is a sui generis arbitral procedure aimed at disposing of a defence which is obviously/on the face of it/self-evidently/manifestly unmeritoious.
- It is a procedure comparable to and with a similar aim as an exception or a summary judgment application in litigious proceedings. The aim is to avoid the unnecessary waste of time and resources associated with a full hearing where the defence obviously/on the face of it/self-evidently/manifestly has no merit.
- An early dismissal arbitral procedure, unlike an expected arbitral procedure, does not include evidence and argument on the merits. It is determined solely ex facie the document/s in which the respondent expressed in its defence. It is an interlocutory/interim process, in nature and aim similar to an exception or a summary judgment application in High Court litigation.
- The key word in article 25.1(a) of the Rules is “manifestly“. It signifies at least two things, namely:
- The authorities referred to above dictate that the standard in an application in terms of article 25 of the Rules is high. Article 25 only applies, and an application in terms thereof can only succeed, where the alleged lack of merit is obvious/manifest from the document in which it is expressed, and the alleged lack of merit is based on undisputed or genuinely indisputable rules of law or uncontested facts. If not, the application must be dismissed and the arbitration must continue.
- With all of the aforesaid in mind, I would suggest that your statement of defence obviously/on the fact of it/self-evidently/manifestly contains a legally recognised defence which justifies and warrants a full ventilation of factual evidence through oral evidence, cross- and re-examination, documentary evidence and argument from both sides in order for the arbitrator to ultimately publish a fully informed and reasoned award.
- Your defence as it appears from your statement of defence evidently constitutes a triable issue.
- In terms of article 18.1 of the Rules you as the respondent have an unqualified right to be “given a reasonable opportunity of presenting its case”. This is not unusual, it is merely a re-statement in plain English of the audi alteram partem principle.
- I light of the above, it appears to me that your defence should on no construction be dismissed as manifestly without either legal or factual merit.
- An award which grants a summary dismissal of your defence, in absence of audi alteram partem in the form of a full hearing of oral and documentary evidence with argument, may very well constitute a reviewable award on the basis as contemplated in article 33(1)(b) of the Arbitration Act of 1995.
In conclusion, my dear Frikkie, I hope that this has contributed to a more complete understanding of article 25 of the Rules.
I wish you all the best in opposing the claimant’s application.
Uncle Oswald
We want to hear from you.
Have you got any questions, comments or feedback? Let us know and we’ll do our best to incorporate the best suggestions. Uncle Oswald is always up for questions.
Missed a Previous Arbitrarily Speaking Issue?
Catch up here.
Note to Parties and Tribunals on the Conduct of ICC Arbitration (1 June 2026).
Mainstream Renewable Power Ltd and Others v Federal republic of Germany (ICSID Case No. ARB/21/26) ICSID final award (13 May 2026).