ANALYSIS OF AN ARBITRATOR’S AWARD – OCTOBER 2026

THE DUTCO PRINCIPLE IN SOUTH AFRICAN CONSTRUCTION ARBITRATION:
WHY FIDIC AND NEC PRACTITIONERS SHOULD PAY ATTENTION

INTRODUCTION

The Association’s Board has endorsed the recommendation of the Rules Committee which suggested that the existing Restricted Representation Rules should be made self-contained and incorporate, expressly, the provisions from the Standard Procedure Rules for the Conduct of Arbitrations which are currently included by reference only.  In addition, that the scope of Rules published by the Association should extend to a set of Expedited Rules to permit more experienced arbitrators to take advantage of the true benefits of arbitration in creating a cost and time effective arbitral process.

The Rules Committee is currently tasked with these two initiatives.  During the course of drafting Expedited Rules, the question of whether a single arbitrator or a Tribunal of three arbitrators, as per the UNCITRAL Expedited Rules, is being considered.  This, in turn, has necessitated taking into account the 1992 French “Dutco” judgment.

This brief article highlights the importance of Dutco and explains why it needs to be considered in the context of our forthcoming Expedited Rules.

THE DUTCO PRINCIPLE AND ITS RELEVANCE TO CONSTRUCTION ARBITRATION IN SOUTH AFRICA

The decision of the French Cour de cassation in BKMI Industrienlagen GmbH & Siemens AG v Dutco Construction Co Ltd (“Dutco”) established a cornerstone of modern international arbitration: the equality of parties in the constitution of the arbitral tribunal.  The Court held that it is contrary to international public policy (ordre public) for parties with potentially divergent interests to be compelled to jointly appoint a single arbitrator, thereby undermining procedural equality.[1]

At its core, the Dutco principle requires that each party be afforded an equal opportunity to participate in the appointment of the tribunal.  This principle cannot be waived in advance and applies with particular force in multi-party arbitrations, where the risk of imbalance is most acute.[2]

APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN ARBITRATION LAW

Although Dutco is a French decision, its underlying principle aligns closely with South African arbitration law and constitutional values.  The International Arbitration Act 15 of 2017 incorporates the UNCITRAL Model Law and emphasises fairness, equality, and due process in arbitral proceedings.  Article 18 provides:

“The parties shall be treated with equality and each party shall be given a full opportunity of presenting his case.”[3]

This principle finds resonance in South African jurisprudence on public policy and procedural fairness.  In Barkhuizen v Napier the Constitutional Court confirmed that contractual provisions are subject to constitutional scrutiny, particularly where they operate unfairly or unreasonably.  Similarly, in Lufuno Mphaphuli & Associates (Pty) Ltd v Andrews the Court emphasised that arbitration must be conducted in a manner consistent with fairness, even where parties have agreed to limit procedural rights.

These authorities support the proposition that procedural inequality in tribunal constitution – such as that identified in Dutco – would likely be regarded as contrary to South African public policy.  This is reinforced by the Model Law provisions permitting the setting aside or refusal of enforcement of an award where the tribunal was improperly constituted.[4]

RELEVANCE TO FIDIC AND NEC CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS

The Dutco principle has significant practical implications in construction arbitration, particularly under FIDIC Conditions of Contract and NEC Engineering and Construction Contract frameworks.

MULTI-PARTY DISPUTES IN FIDIC PROJECTS

FIDIC projects frequently involve joint ventures, subcontractors and multiple stakeholders.  Disputes referred to arbitration – often following an adjudication process – may therefore involve multiple respondents or claimants.  Where multiple parties are treated as a single ‘side’ and required to nominate a single arbitrator, a Dutco issue may arise if their interests diverge.

This is particularly relevant in joint venture disputes, where internal allocation of liability may differ from the external position advanced against the Employer.  In such circumstances, compelling a joint nomination risks infringing the principle of equality may expose the award to challenge.

Institutional arbitration rules have evolved to address this risk by empowering appointing authorities to constitute the tribunal where necessary to preserve equality.[5]

NEC AND ADJUDICATION TO ARBITRATION PATHWAYS

Under NEC contracts, disputes typically proceed first to adjudication before arbitration.  However, in complex infrastructure projects involving multiple contractors or consultants, similar risks arise at the arbitration stage.

South African courts have repeatedly stressed the importance of procedural fairness in adjudicative processes.  The reasoning in Barkhuizen and Lufuno suggest that, even where parties have agreed to a particular procedure, it must not result in substantive unfairness.  Accordingly, any arbitration arrangement under NEC that results in unequal influence over tribunal appointment would be vulnerable to challenge.

PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS

For South African practitioners and adjudicators the implications are clear.  Care must be taken in drafting and applying arbitration agreements in multi-party contexts.  Institutional arbitration is generally preferable, given its safeguards for balanced tribunal constitution.  In ad hoc proceedings explicit mechanisms should be included to ensure independent and equitable appointment of arbitrators.

Where such safeguards are absent a court may be required to intervene to preserve equality, failing which the enforceability of any resulting award may be jeopardised.

CONCLUSION

The Dutco principle underscores that the legitimacy of an arbitral award begins with the fairness of the tribunal’s constitution.  In the context of South African construction arbitration – particularly under FIDIC and NEC forms – this principle is not merely persuasive but finds support in constitutional norms and Model Law principles.  It therefore serves as an important safeguard in ensuring that arbitral outcomes are both procedurally fair and legally enforceable.

 

Chris Binnington

Director, Rules Committee Chair


Missed a Previous Arbitrarily Speaking Issue?

Catch up here.


[1] BKMI Industrienlagen GmbH & Siemens AG v Dutso Construction Co Ltd, French Cour de cassation, 7 January 1992.

[2]  See generally international arbitration commentary recognising equality in tribunal constitution as a fundamental procedural guarantee.

[3] UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (1985, as amended), Article 18, incorporated into South African law by the International Arbitration Act 15 of 2017.

[4]  Ibid., Articles 34(2)(a)(iv) and 36(1)(a)(iv).

[5]  See, for example, International Chamber of Commerce Arbitration Rules (current edition), provisions relating to multi-party appointment of arbitrators.